How insights work

I started writing a post explaining that psychotic episodes are like conceptual breakthrough insights, except that they’re wrong and therefore persistent delusions. But I ended up writing several paragraphs of background material and running out of time. Therefore…background material in small chunks.

Insight comes from the compulsive recombinant behavior of the occipital lobe (at least the sort I have to constantly deal with). This is the brain constantly generating mostly nonsense questions and hypotheses like “Is it possible to look at a square at a certain angle and see a triangle?” Every now and then, the occipital comes up with a useful hypothesis for modeling the outside world: “Ozzy’s gene mutation that breaks down alcohol efficiently comes from neanderthals.” In the occipital’s style of cognition, a useful theory is one that is both highly explanatory and predictive. That is, a lot of different hypotheses happen to fit together nicely, and ratio isn’t complaining about internal contradictions or perceptual data that contradicts the theory.

So these useful theories have been rolling around in the unconscious for a while, collecting other ideas that fit into their various paradigms and “stick” onto them like giant katamaris. When one of these gets big enough, it may be passed on to the conscious mind as an “insight”. The conscious mind experiences this as a flash of insight containing a single, simple idea, followed by a short period (a few minutes) I call the “exposition”. The insight is experienced as being of paramount importance for reasons that aren’t quite understood until the exposition gets rolling, but this is an important mechanism because the exposition requires a short period of obsessive introspection. Often, the insight is triggered by an external event requiring an explanation, maybe a headline on the news like “Hijackers Fly Planes Into Twin Towers”, and the unconscious is all like “Hey bro, remember when we read Spengler? Well, I’ve been working on that paradigm for a while and it might explain this, so you can try it out for a bit. Here’s how it works…”

The exposition is a period where the unconscious teaches a theory to the conscious. The conscious mind experiences this as a singular idea which is examined from several angles to reveal a bunch of important implications and applications (which is just the gradual revelation of ideas that stuck to the katamari). I think this is why it often manifests, in the imagination, as a sort of heavily one-sided dialogue. John C. Wright’s character Menelaus Montrose does this in Count to a Trillion when he’s in some sort of coma, IIRC. His unconscious mind invents a character who teaches him the math he’s going to need when he wakes up. In my imaginative experience, the one soliloquizing to a captive audience is “me”, but that’s probably a sort of projection (and a lot like blogging, incidentally). Then again, Menelaus is a post-human with an IQ higher than his planet-sized crystal computing thingamajig, Pellucid, whereas I’m just this guy, so maybe the criticism is unjustified :-P.

Anyway, I think a good way to imagine this process is to picture the conscious mind as a precocious kid who’s mother has told him he needs to clean and organize his toys, and the unconscious mind as a mute servant/caretaker who knew this was coming and has already been working on the arrangements. (I call the occipital “the old man in back” for this reason.) The kid turns around to see shelves, boxes, and drawers already set up for him. The old man then demonstrates how they can be used to organize the toys, slowly placing each toy in a particular place, while the kid sort of narrates his gradual understanding.

“Oh I see, all of the Transformers can go on the same shelf here…(the old man nods)…and all of the stuffed animals can go in the box because they won’t break…(the old man nods again)…and the extra bedding can go in the dresser…(the old man shakes his head)…oh, I guess it wouldn’t fit, would it…(the old man nods)…” Et cetera, until the kid has fully understood the idea.

As an example, consider the bit about Ozzy’s drinking mutation above. Maybe one or two of you read that and were like “Whoa, everything makes sense now!” But the rest weren’t really sure where that idea came from. Here’s what an exposition might look like: Ice people often have alcoholic drinking habits. Thals change mental modes under the influence of even small amounts of alcohol, which is similar to being a functioning alcoholic (specifically within the social sphere). Otherwise, thals are in deepsock mode. Ozzy in particular has lots of neanderthal admixture. Maybe alcohol was a social ritual of sorts for thals, telling them “the work day is over, relax and socialize now”. Maybe this ritual led to increased tolerance over time, favoring people who experienced the mental switch without poisoning themselves as much.

Advertisements

About Aeoli Pera

Maybe do this later?
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to How insights work

  1. Legionnaire says:

    -It was said that no matter how much he drank, Socrates would never get drunk.
    -It is thought the peasant laborers in Sumeria and other early civilizations were paid in beer.
    http://www.thumotic.com/alcohol-hurting/
    https://badgerhut.wordpress.com/2013/04/22/upping-your-status-with-the-right-drink/
    http://alphagameplan.blogspot.com/2012/05/bloody-peasants.html

    Insight porn on the subject of alcohol. Let your occipital run wild.

  2. Heaviside says:

    “What the German spirit might be — who has not had his melancholy ideas about that! But this people has deliberately made itself stupid, for nearly a millennium: nowhere have the two great European narcotics, alcohol and Christianity, been abused more dissolutely. Recently even a third has been added — one that alone would be suffficient to dispatch all fine and bold fiexibility of the spirit — music, our constipated, constipating German music. How much disgruntled heaviness, lameness, dampness, dressing gown — how much beer there is in the German intelligence! How is it at all possible that young men who dedicate their lives to the most spiritual goals do not feel the first instinct of spirituality, the spirit’s instinct of self-preservation — and drink beer? The alcoholism of young scholars is perhaps no question mark concerning their scholarliness — without spirit one can still be a great scholar — but in every other respect it remains a problem. Where would one not find the gentle degeneration which beer produces in the spirit? Once, in a case that has almost become famous, I put my finger on such a degeneration — the degeneration of our number-one German free spirit, the clever David Strauss, into the author of a beer-bench gospel and “new faith.” It was not for nothing that he had made his vow to the “fair brunette” [dark beer] in verse — loyalty unto death.”

  3. Craig says:

    Ahh thanks, you have read me, I remember you I think I’m right, I have to spend more time reading your blog, satellite is playing up with the storms, so net intermittent. Bloody drought with my sand filter, had to find another adaption for salty bore water, which takes more energy, it needs twice the aeration and filtering unfortunately compared to normal dam water. Every thing green and full now so all good. Thanks to rain. Came off a dry 5 1/2 month drought.

    OK this will sound like a weird question, with your writers block is it a problem with dreaming, too much or too little, or too intense?

    Or do you just need to calm down and relax, you know like after work?

    Certainly sounds like you need to order the clatter out, mediation is good for that.

    I have very few dreams any more at night, so just day dreaming now,I kinda do that on purpose though, with the right herb. You’d be surprised most herbs that sync with our frequencies are legal… Passion fruit flower and root, which can help in relaxation or the breaking of addiction, nicotine for example. Smoker shops in Aus managed to ban passion fruit flower ciggs federally, when they realised customers were using it to wean off. So passion fruit flower ciggs are now a class 4 drug by law.. no more imports..

    With medicine be it pharmaceutical or herbal there’s always a trade off, can’t get something for nothing. I mean that in a bodily sense not financial.

    I was thinking my mate with the ADD is of Irish decent, that new genetic discovery in regards to more efficient Iron uptake in the Irish, and how they’re predisposed to Iron poisoning… eh could be epigentically influenced by diet in some cases. I’m going to have to speak to him now. :-) So thanks. Makes sense to me now why his white skin was always an off greenish colour rather then a healthy pink…

  4. Aeoli Pera says:

    >Ahh thanks, you have read me, I remember you I think I’m right, I have to spend more time reading your blog, satellite is playing up with the storms, so net intermittent. Bloody drought with my sand filter, had to find another adaption for salty bore water, which takes more energy, it needs twice the aeration and filtering unfortunately compared to normal dam water. Every thing green and full now so all good. Thanks to rain. Came off a dry 5 1/2 month drought.

    Actually, I had no idea the sand filter was even within the realm of possibility. Thought I was making up a technofancy idea out of thin air. You’ll have to link to your work for me.

    >OK this will sound like a weird question, with your writers block is it a problem with dreaming, too much or too little, or too intense?

    I’ve been dreaming a great deal more than usual, recently. These dreams also have a note of urgency to them, as if my subconscious is desperately trying to get through to me.

    >Or do you just need to calm down and relax, you know like after work? // Certainly sounds like you need to order the clatter out, mediation is good for that.

    I’m having both problems at once. Cognitive dissonance at work and cognitive dissonance due to imagination overload.

    >Smoker shops in Aus managed to ban passion fruit flower ciggs federally, when they realised customers were using it to wean off. So passion fruit flower ciggs are now a class 4 drug by law.. no more imports..

    This inspired the new post on “anti-intuition”.

    >I was thinking my mate with the ADD is of Irish decent, that new genetic discovery in regards to more efficient Iron uptake in the Irish, and how they’re predisposed to Iron poisoning… eh could be epigentically influenced by diet in some cases. I’m going to have to speak to him now. :-) So thanks. Makes sense to me now why his white skin was always an off greenish colour rather then a healthy pink…

    No opinion, but thanks for the insight.

  5. Pingback: Hit you in the eye | Aeoli Pera

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s