Possible mechanism for Overton window shift

I came up with this almost by accident in some comments on this VP post and just rolled with the idea. These are in chronological order.


It just occurred to me that when SJWs and other forms of shitlib fervently believe that controlling people’s word choice will control their thoughts and behavior…they’re projecting.

This has immediate applications for controlling their behavior.

E.g. It’s not immigration, it’s “human trafficking”. [Ref]


At the institutional level, it’s impossible to make mean-sounding changes. You can’t get people to use dysphemisms like executive order = diktat, even though that’s exactly what it is, because that’s not nice. The Church of Nice People is the dominant religion in the West now, so the only narrative changes that can be accepted are nice-sounding euphemisms for things we support.

So according to this logic “human trafficking” wouldn’t fly. But “respecting” might, even though it’s tongue-in-cheek. I think “cultural reunification” would go over better for deportation.


The negative stuff like “Immigration is Rape Culture” works well at the id level. This cultural pressure on the id provides the impetus for political change. But political change requires an acceptable formulation that can be discussed by nice people in nice conversation, i.e. post-facto rationalization by the ego. The ego needs permission to accede to the id pressure.

This constructive use of euphemisms is like a pressure valve on the European id. For years, progressives have been using these valves to direct id pressure into propulsion.

Hmm.


Okay, I think I have reverse-engineered how the Overton window always shifts left, whereas the question of why is left to other models such as evil and r-selection.

The extreme leftists win at the intellectual and cultural levels. The intellectuals (like Mill or Gramsci) create tactics and art, which the other extremists turn into id pressure (like Marx or Hollywood). People absorb the cultural stuff, creating inner anxiety and a desire to fix issue X, but out loud they’re forced to reject the “extremists” because they’re too negative. This is where the moderate leftists suggest nice ways to fix X, providing the outlet and thus leftward propulsion.


This theory is so obvious in retrospect that I’m probably embarrassing myself.

Were-Puppy wrote:
You need to work Trump into your theory because he has wrecked the left shift handily.

The Trump phenomenon is pure id expression, whereas the Overton window is memetics. The former is concerned with desire and what actions people take and what is occasionally voiced in hushed whispers or anonymous dark corners of the internet. The latter is concerned with what you’re allowed to say in nice places like the workplace or around the family dinner table.

Notice that the most white midwits (the most nice demo) are supporting Bernie Sanders (anti-establishment but tame) whereas Trump supporters are the groups with less tact and more outrage (id:nice ratio is higher).


Bringing this back to the original post, the id message of burning a flag, regardless of the author, is “somebody doesn’t like the gays”. Successful R-selected people (vs. simply dysgenic, see here) apparently do this directed propulsion thing instinctively, or so saith the great anonymous one. So even though there’s a lot of built-up anger on the right, these sorts of passive-aggressive expressions of id stuff simply don’t occur to them. They prefer real violence of the focused, organized sort, not maybe sorta implied future flash mob violence.

Therefore this [from the original post] is probably true:

The best part is that there are better than even odds that the rainbow flag was torched by an SJW seeking to play the victim and drum up outrage.


Nick S wrote:

Aeoli Pera wrote:
This is where the moderate leftists suggest nice ways to fix X, providing the outlet and thus leftward propulsion.

You may be on to something. It’s like a placebo effect for alleviating cognitive dissonance/angst that is really still there if they think about it too much. They’re just tricking themselves into thinking they’re solving problems, but it’s a feedback loop that provides perpetual problems to be pseudo-solved.

More or less. “Never let a crisis go to waste.” It works both ways, like any other behavioral training tactic. Or any direction really, it just takes a little Machiavellianism, a specific goal (like flooding the West with immigrants), and a cultural injection of id stuff.

Advertisements

About Aeoli Pera

Maybe do this later?
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Possible mechanism for Overton window shift

  1. Edenist whackjob says:

    Here in Sweden, the “åsiktskorridor” (opinion corridor, Overton window) has widened dramatically since about August of last year.

    It’s really ridiculous, if welcome, to see journalists talking common sense about immigration as if that wouldn’t have rendered them fully Berufsverbot’ed one year ago.

    It was hilarious to see the police going “the reason we didn’t report about immigrant crimes is because the media would have destroyed us”, then seeing the media accuse the police of covering up immigrant crimes.

    I have actually considered that this massive shift in the Swedish media is the reason for my recent upturn in sanity as well. The fact that I was right such a crucial issue (ie immigration bad for Sweden) all these years has caused a chain reaction in my psyche where I conclude again and again that my rational logic was correct, unlocking further sanity.

    • Aeoli Pera says:

      >It’s really ridiculous, if welcome, to see journalists talking common sense about immigration as if that wouldn’t have rendered them fully Berufsverbot’ed one year ago.

      Don’t forgive and don’t forget. They have not suddenly turned over a new leaf, they are just adapting to the situation.

      >It was hilarious to see the police going “the reason we didn’t report about immigrant crimes is because the media would have destroyed us”, then seeing the media accuse the police of covering up immigrant crimes.

      CYA. These rabbits understand their lives are at risk now and they would throw their own mothers to the wolves just to get a step ahead.

      Your reaction suggests naivete. These people still want to genocide your nation, they just realize that they’ve overplayed for the moment.

      >I have actually considered that this massive shift in the Swedish media is the reason for my recent upturn in sanity as well. The fact that I was right such a crucial issue (ie immigration bad for Sweden) all these years has caused a chain reaction in my psyche where I conclude again and again that my rational logic was correct, unlocking further sanity.

      The upturn in your sanity is from the people around you becoming sane. Put a sane man in the psych ward and tell the doctors he’s psychotic, and the sane man will be driven nuts.

      Hey, that sounds like normal life, doesn’t it?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s