Identity as idea

There’s an overcorrection, common in the ‘sphere, that identity politics obviates ideas. This is only a partial truth. When we talk about “ideas” in this sense we mean that two parties agree on values (preferred ends) and have differing opinions on how to reach those ends (optimal means). So a libertarian and a conservative may agree that government is a necessary evil at best, but they may disagree on the implications this has for tax policy. In general these two men can be reconciled because, although they view each other as competition, they agree that the better man ought to win the better gal and live in the bigger house and the lesser man ought to settle for the lesser gal and the smaller house (similar values/ends). But some identities can’t be reconciled because one or both wants the other dead or celibate and servile. In this case, discussion of means is futile because they have mutually incompatible ends.

Now, I’d like to propose the idea that identity is a deeply held idea, hiding below conscious awareness. This is where that shadowy self-talk comes from which resists refutation, drives behavior, and shapes our lives, such as “I’m black” or “We’re all in this together” or “Everybody cheats a little”. Sometimes these subliminal priors are realistic (“I could do better”), sometimes they’re metaphorical approximations (“The world is made of lies”), and sometimes they’re detached from reality (“Girls ought to be sexually aroused by my intelligence”). These deeply held ideas are generally intractable because they frame the way we process new information, and so they produce behavioral fixations by the same process that repeated misdirection of the sex drive into perverted expression/neural activation reinforces sexual fixations (i.e. fetishes).

According to my theory of origin myths, these ideas can be inherited through genetics as emotional formulas, in addition to cultural transmission. Boys don’t need to be taught the Hero’s Journey because their male ancestors lived through the male coming-of-age story over and over until it was hardcoded into their limbic systems. I believe this is where group averages in temperament and behavioral fixation come from. Examples:

-As the dog returns to its vomit, so the Irishman returns to his feuds.
-As the fool returns to his folly, so the conservative returns to his armchair.
-As the woman returns to her abuser, so the Edenist returns to his neurosis.

It appears that deeply held ideas are relatively easy to form (in “formative” years) but quite difficult to change. The only phenomenon that appears to be able to change a deeply held idea is an epiphany. People don’t change overnight, except every now and then they do, as in religious conversions, near-death experiences, and psychedelic trips. Epiphanies are relatively rare, but they do happen, and I believe it’s possible to study them and create environments where they are more likely to happen.

About Aeoli Pera

Maybe do this later?
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

13 Responses to Identity as idea

  1. Tolian says:

    “People don’t change overnight, except every now and then they do, as in religious conversions, near-death experiences, and psychedelic trips. Epiphanies are relatively rare, but they do happen, and I believe it’s possible to study them and create environments where they are more likely to happen.”

    This is the problem with Normies. They know change takes time, but they will constantly harrass you to get stuff done right now. Its like their brain is able to understand the real world, but operates in fantasy land when they encounter a non-normie.

  2. Koanic says:

    You should have given an example of whatever problem it is you’re trying to fix at the beginning.

  3. bicebicebice says:

    http://www.pnas.org/content/114/35/9314.short bottoms up, the sape nasal spray wasn’t for the sapes, it was for us

  4. Ø says:

    >”Girls ought to be sexually aroused by my intelligence”
    >detached from reality

    Only partially so. Insofar as its appeal to women is concerned, intelligence is like a seasoning or spice that improves the overall quality of the meal but doesn’t hold up on its own. Give her tinglies in an intelligent way, great. Recite the contents of the SICP to her, not so great.

    • Tolian says:

      lt goes beyond that. Theyve been conditioned to find things such as smarts repulsive and digusting. Men also take the things they think women find attractive to the extreme. Guys think their cars make them attractive. No women in her right mind would tell a man his priveliged steed is a piece of garbage. Which means a lot of women are enabling the warren. However, the decent ones who are worth keeping around dont care and I quote from a true story “Its disgusting. I could not stand talking to him. Its like he was using his car as a surrogate for his manhood.”

  5. glosoli says:

    Today I baked my first cake and made soup for the second time, am I now a chef?
    I think so, it was very tasty.

  6. Sunnybutt says:

    Someone has studied deep personality changes, and created environments where they’re more likely to happen. Pick up “Snapping: America’s Epidemic of Sudden Personality Change” by Flo Conway and Jim Seigelman.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s